I just want to get everyones opinion on best specialities for a given position and why. My current preferred order list is:
Defenders
Powerful
-gain some Scoring(not really important), Defending and Playmaking in the rain
-According to hattristics the positive effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-lose some Scoring(not really important) in the sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 16% of all sun matches
-lose more stamina in the sun, can have a negative effect
-improves pressing tactic
Unpredictable(Assuming has high defending)
-sufficient defending eliminates negative effect
-good passing can create chance
-According to hattristics the negative event being converted for DEFs is 1.1% (~1/99 matches)
-According to hattristics the positive event for DEFs chance of happening is 2.7% (~1/37 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 54.8% (~1/67.5 matches)
Head
-improves chance of scoring on a SP
-can have negative effect from Technical wingers and forwards
-each add. adds about 7% avg chance for a header event
-each add. reduces about .5% avg chance for opponent a header event
Quick(Do not recommend)
-can stop quick event from wingers and forwards
-lose some Scoring and Defending in rain
-lose some Defending in sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect for defenders from weather is 20.1% (1/5 matches)
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 17% of all sun matches
IM
Technical
-gain some Scoring(not really important) and Playmaking in sun
-lose some Scoring(not really important) and Playmaking in rain
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 31% of all rain matches
-According to hattristics the positive effect from weather happens 32% of all sun matches
Head
-improves chance of scoring on a SP
-can have negative effect from Technical wingers and forwards
-each add. adds about 7% avg chance for a header event
-each add. reduces about .5% avg chance for opponent a header event
Powerful
-gain some Scoring(not really important), Defending and Playmaking in the rain
-According to hattristics the positive effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-lose some Scoring(not really important) in the sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 16% of all sun matches
-lose more stamina in the sun, can have a negative effect
-improves pressing tactic
Quick
-can stop quick event from wingers and forwards
-lose some Scoring(not really important) and Defending in rain
-lose some Defending in sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect for IMs from weather is 19.2% (~1/5 matches)
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 17% of all sun matches
Unpredictable
-good passing can create chance
-According to hattristics the negative event being converted for DEFs is 2.5% (~1/40 matches)
-According to hattristics the positive event for DEFs chance of happening is 3.4% (~1/34 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 55.9% (~1/60.8 matches)
WI
Technical
-create chances if an opposing defender or inner midfielder is a head specialist
-gain some Scoring(not really important) and Playmaking in sun
-lose some Scoring(not really important) and Playmaking in rain
Head
-improves chance of scoring on a SP
-can have a positive effect from winger event
-each add. adds about 7% avg chance for a header event
-each add. reduces about .5% avg chance for opponent a header event
Quick
-can create quick event
-lose some Scoring(not really important) and Defending in rain
-lose some Defending in sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect for WIs from weather is 18.9% (~1/5 matches)
-According to hattristics the positive effect for WIs chance of happening is 15.3% (~1/6.75 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 60.6% (~1/11.14 matches)
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 17% of all sun matches
Powerful
-gain some Scoring(not really important), Defending and Playmaking in the rain
-According to hattristics the positive effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-lose some Scoring(not really important) in the sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 16% of all sun matches
-lose more stamina in the sun, can have a negative effect
-improves pressing tactic
Unpredictable
-good passing can create chance
-According to hattristics the negative event being converted for WIs is 0%
-According to hattristics the positive event for WIs chance of happening is 5.6% (~1/18 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 43.8% (~1/41 matches)
FW
Technical
-create chances if an opposing defender or inner midfielder is a head specialist
-gain some Scoring and Playmaking in sun
-lose some Scoring and Playmaking in rain
Head
-improves chance of scoring on a SP
-can have a positive effect from winger event
-each add. adds about 7% avg chance for a header event
-each add. reduces about .5% avg chance for opponent a header event
Quick
-can create quick event
-lose some Scoring and Defending(not really important) in rain
-lose some Defending(not really important) in sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect for FWs from weather is 14.6% (~1/7 matches)
-According to hattristics the positive effect for FWs chance of happening is 16.2% (~1/6.25 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 81.7% (~1/7.65 matches)
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 17% of all sun matches
Unpredictable
-good passing can create chance
-can use scoring skill to intercept the ball
-unpredictability itself may also create unlikely scoring opportunities
-According to hattristics the negative event being converted for FWs is 0%
-According to hattristics the positive event for WIs chance of happening is 5.6% (~1/18 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 43.8% (~1/41 matches)
---------------
Def
1) Head - useful in all positions really
2) Powerful - very useful if you are a defensive team and likely to press but in most cases I would still prefer Heads
3) Unpredictable - under-rated as a useful spec on a defender though really need reasonable passing.
IM
1) Head
2) Powerful if decent stamina
I would also consider Technical if you would like to have a mix of weather dependant IMs in your squad, unpredictable only if he has decent defence and passing skills and quick only if to use a lot as a WTM.
WG
1) Quick
2) Head
3) Unpredictable
4) Technical
FW
1) Quick
2) Head
3) Unpredictable
4) Technical
I may in some cases shuffle Unpredictable above Head for forward or winger dependant on how many other Head specialists I had in team and having a Head specialist at either forward or wing can be useful to finish off a winger SE but an Unpredictable would then be useful as a 2nd winger or 2nd/3rd forward.
Defenders
Powerful
-gain some Scoring(not really important), Defending and Playmaking in the rain
-According to hattristics the positive effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-lose some Scoring(not really important) in the sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 16% of all sun matches
-lose more stamina in the sun, can have a negative effect
-improves pressing tactic
Unpredictable(Assuming has high defending)
-sufficient defending eliminates negative effect
-good passing can create chance
-According to hattristics the negative event being converted for DEFs is 1.1% (~1/99 matches)
-According to hattristics the positive event for DEFs chance of happening is 2.7% (~1/37 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 54.8% (~1/67.5 matches)
Head
-improves chance of scoring on a SP
-can have negative effect from Technical wingers and forwards
-each add. adds about 7% avg chance for a header event
-each add. reduces about .5% avg chance for opponent a header event
Quick(Do not recommend)
-can stop quick event from wingers and forwards
-lose some Scoring and Defending in rain
-lose some Defending in sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect for defenders from weather is 20.1% (1/5 matches)
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 17% of all sun matches
IM
Technical
-gain some Scoring(not really important) and Playmaking in sun
-lose some Scoring(not really important) and Playmaking in rain
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 31% of all rain matches
-According to hattristics the positive effect from weather happens 32% of all sun matches
Head
-improves chance of scoring on a SP
-can have negative effect from Technical wingers and forwards
-each add. adds about 7% avg chance for a header event
-each add. reduces about .5% avg chance for opponent a header event
Powerful
-gain some Scoring(not really important), Defending and Playmaking in the rain
-According to hattristics the positive effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-lose some Scoring(not really important) in the sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 16% of all sun matches
-lose more stamina in the sun, can have a negative effect
-improves pressing tactic
Quick
-can stop quick event from wingers and forwards
-lose some Scoring(not really important) and Defending in rain
-lose some Defending in sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect for IMs from weather is 19.2% (~1/5 matches)
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 17% of all sun matches
Unpredictable
-good passing can create chance
-According to hattristics the negative event being converted for DEFs is 2.5% (~1/40 matches)
-According to hattristics the positive event for DEFs chance of happening is 3.4% (~1/34 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 55.9% (~1/60.8 matches)
WI
Technical
-create chances if an opposing defender or inner midfielder is a head specialist
-gain some Scoring(not really important) and Playmaking in sun
-lose some Scoring(not really important) and Playmaking in rain
Head
-improves chance of scoring on a SP
-can have a positive effect from winger event
-each add. adds about 7% avg chance for a header event
-each add. reduces about .5% avg chance for opponent a header event
Quick
-can create quick event
-lose some Scoring(not really important) and Defending in rain
-lose some Defending in sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect for WIs from weather is 18.9% (~1/5 matches)
-According to hattristics the positive effect for WIs chance of happening is 15.3% (~1/6.75 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 60.6% (~1/11.14 matches)
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 17% of all sun matches
Powerful
-gain some Scoring(not really important), Defending and Playmaking in the rain
-According to hattristics the positive effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-lose some Scoring(not really important) in the sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 16% of all sun matches
-lose more stamina in the sun, can have a negative effect
-improves pressing tactic
Unpredictable
-good passing can create chance
-According to hattristics the negative event being converted for WIs is 0%
-According to hattristics the positive event for WIs chance of happening is 5.6% (~1/18 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 43.8% (~1/41 matches)
FW
Technical
-create chances if an opposing defender or inner midfielder is a head specialist
-gain some Scoring and Playmaking in sun
-lose some Scoring and Playmaking in rain
Head
-improves chance of scoring on a SP
-can have a positive effect from winger event
-each add. adds about 7% avg chance for a header event
-each add. reduces about .5% avg chance for opponent a header event
Quick
-can create quick event
-lose some Scoring and Defending(not really important) in rain
-lose some Defending(not really important) in sun
-According to hattristics the negative effect for FWs from weather is 14.6% (~1/7 matches)
-According to hattristics the positive effect for FWs chance of happening is 16.2% (~1/6.25 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 81.7% (~1/7.65 matches)
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 30% of all rain matches
-According to hattristics the negative effect from weather happens 17% of all sun matches
Unpredictable
-good passing can create chance
-can use scoring skill to intercept the ball
-unpredictability itself may also create unlikely scoring opportunities
-According to hattristics the negative event being converted for FWs is 0%
-According to hattristics the positive event for WIs chance of happening is 5.6% (~1/18 matches)
-According to hattristics the conversion rate for this event is 43.8% (~1/41 matches)
---------------
Def
1) Head - useful in all positions really
2) Powerful - very useful if you are a defensive team and likely to press but in most cases I would still prefer Heads
3) Unpredictable - under-rated as a useful spec on a defender though really need reasonable passing.
IM
1) Head
2) Powerful if decent stamina
I would also consider Technical if you would like to have a mix of weather dependant IMs in your squad, unpredictable only if he has decent defence and passing skills and quick only if to use a lot as a WTM.
WG
1) Quick
2) Head
3) Unpredictable
4) Technical
FW
1) Quick
2) Head
3) Unpredictable
4) Technical
I may in some cases shuffle Unpredictable above Head for forward or winger dependant on how many other Head specialists I had in team and having a Head specialist at either forward or wing can be useful to finish off a winger SE but an Unpredictable would then be useful as a 2nd winger or 2nd/3rd forward.
